Skip to content
Back to articles
3 min read

What it costs to start operational readiness at FEL-3 instead of FEL-2

The difference is not in the readiness budget. It is in the cost of closing the same gap after basic engineering and procurement are already committed.

The question comes up in almost every investment review: can we start the readiness work at FEL-3? The short answer is yes. The useful answer is what it costs.

What changes between FEL-2 and FEL-3

At FEL-2, required capability is still being defined and design alternatives are open. If the analysis shows the plant needs margin in a particular system to sustain stable throughput, that margin goes into the design. If it shows critical competence does not exist in the local market, the training plan enters the schedule and the budget.

At FEL-3, basic engineering is frozen and much of procurement is committed. The same analysis remains possible, but the alternatives have changed in nature. Margin that was not designed in now requires later modification; competence that was not developed now requires specialist hires at the moment they are most expensive and least available.

An example with declared numbers

Take an availability gap of four percentage points in a plant running 7,000 hours a year with a contribution margin of USD 6,000 per hour. The value at risk through the availability route is roughly USD 1.7 million per year of exposure.

Closing that gap at FEL-2 is typically an engineering decision: redundancy in a critical system, a revised maintenance strategy or an adjusted specification. The cost is a fraction of the value at risk.

Closing the same gap after start-up means intervening in a running plant, with shutdowns, emergency contracting and reduced output. The cost of closure stops being an engineering line item and starts competing with the value at risk on worse terms.

The argument is not about starting earlier

The argument is not that readiness should start earlier for methodological discipline. It is that the same work carries different prices across the life cycle, and the decision to postpone is an economic decision that is rarely recorded as one.

When the readiness programme starts at FEL-3, the organisation does not save the cost of the programme. It moves part of that cost to the phase where it is highest — and signs for the remainder as production below plan.

What to do with that information

If the project is already at FEL-3 or beyond, the right question is no longer "when do we start" but "which gaps can still be closed at an acceptable cost". Answering it requires three things: required capability declared per pillar, value at risk quantified per route, and estimated closure cost in each remaining phase.

With those three numbers, the decision to close, close in phases or accept stops being a matter of opinion.